When Atheists Attack!
A web friend of mine, Repairman_Jack, recently asked a pretty interesting and important question:
"My question still is: Why are you trying so hard to convince people that their beliefs are wrong?"
I responded in the previous post, but wanted to recreate that response as a separate post (with some additions):
I used to be in the mindset that people should believe hwatever they want as long as they aren't hurting other people, but I've come to the conclusion that an individual's belief in the Bible (or other superstitions) does hurt other people. Belief in these things often takes people away from handling life situations in a way that will truly help and rather they put these things "up to God's will" and take a back seat approach and just pray about it. They rely less on science and rational thought (though they accept scientific advances in medicine, etc typically) and trust mythical supernatural creatures instead. The less rational and realistic society is, the worse we all are for it.
Look at Bush - he's trying to promote Intelligent Design, he uses Christian God references to justify America's actions (right or wrong, the actions shouldn't be justified by some mythical being that most of the world does not believe in and a religion and religious stance that's abhorred by a lot of the world).
Then look to my child's upbringing. If she wants to learn about people's beliefs in a god or other supernatural things when she has a rational mind, more power to her. I will not subject her to different people's beliefs now when she readily believes in creatures like Santa Claus, the Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy, however. Also indoctrination of these ideas at this young age (almost 4) is something that's tough to think through rationally later in life when she's capable of doing it. (also think about the fact that most people born in Israel are Jews, Middle East are Arabs, US are Christians - it's not about rational thought but moreso indoctrination to these beliefs as a child). Unfortunatly, however, I'm surrounded by many people who believe in a Christian god and who share these ideas with her now. I don't want her mind polluted with superstition and myths at this young age.
And probably MOST importantly, my issue with the teaching of various religions and religious ideas to people is that people only hear part of the story. I could teach the Bible (or any other religion) to people who are naive, desperate, searching, and convince them it is the 'truth' by showing parts of the texts and leaving out the obvious issues. The Bible is full of contradictions, statements that are absolutely false (rabbits chew cud, etc) amoung other insanities. My main request of any believer is to look past your preacher's pulpit for information on your religion. If you look at information that is critical of your beliefs with an open mind, you will either:
- Decide these issues are false and come away a stronger believer in your faith. - Decide your particular beliefs are false and not in line with God - Decide your beliefs are completely false and either suspend your belief in god and the supernatural or look for 'the truth'.
Any of these scenarios is a positive one. Let's imagine that a particular Christian sect is the 'True Religion' and you were raised Jewish. How would you find the True Religion if you never looked outside of your belief? How could God be upset about a person validating his beliefs by looking elsewhere when so many people are following False Religions? Yet so many preachers, etc condemn people from looking beyond what they're taught because they're afraid they may find the Truth.
For Christians, I can't recommend the newsletters on this page any more strongly. They are by far the best writings on the errancy of the Bible that I have ever read. You owe it to yourself and your faith to read these newsletters with an open mind.
http://members.aol.com/ckbloomfld/
In short, I definitely believe that people's belief in the supernatural is detrimental to the society because it affects politics, scientific knowledge and rational thought. The mere fact that they trust their beliefs without any sort of question and especially in the face of credible evidence that their beliefs are wrong is a serious example of the problem.
And to those that think they know they are on the right path because they 'feel God/Jesus in their lives', I have something to share. I was once a devout follower of Christianity before I started to explore the nagging questions I had about my faith. While I was a believer, I felt God and felt incredible peace and an incredible presence in my life. Since I've rejected God, I've felt the same way! It's a feeling that all humans experience - it's just applied to a supernatural creature by some. To me, I apply it to feeling amazing. |